Commit Graph

13069 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Tim van der Meij
c4255fdbfd
Merge pull request #12059 from Snuffleupagus/image-class
Convert the code in `src/core/image.js` to use ES6 classes
2020-07-05 14:08:55 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
4ef43ca44b
Merge pull request #12057 from Snuffleupagus/BaseLocalCache-onlyRefs
Allow `BaseLocalCache` to, optionally, only allocate storage for caching of references (PR 12034 follow-up)
2020-07-05 14:05:45 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
59da1d5829 Convert the code in src/core/image.js to use ES6 classes
This removes additional `// eslint-disable-next-line no-shadow` usage, which our old pseudo-classes necessitated.

*Please note:* I'm purposely not doing any `var` to `let`/`const` conversion here, since it's generally better to (if possible) do that automatically on e.g. a directory basis instead.
2020-07-05 09:34:14 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
85ced3fbfd Allow BaseLocalCache to, optionally, only allocate storage for caching of references (PR 12034 follow-up)
*Yet another instalment in the never-ending series of things that you think of __after__ a patch has landed.*

Since `Function`s are only cached by reference, we thus don't need to allocate storage for names in `LocalFunctionCache` instances. Obviously the effect of these changes are *really tiny*, but it seems reasonable in principle to avoid allocating data structures that are guaranteed to be unused.
2020-07-04 15:01:32 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
29548ad498
Merge pull request #12034 from Snuffleupagus/Function-local-cache-3
Add local caching of `Function`s, by reference, in the `PDFFunctionFactory` (issue 2541)
2020-07-04 12:05:15 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
ca719ecaa4 Add local caching of Functions, by reference, in the PDFFunctionFactory (issue 2541)
Note that compared other structures, such as e.g. Images and ColorSpaces, `Function`s are not referred to by name, which however does bring the advantage of being able to share the cache for an *entire* page.
Furthermore, similar to ColorSpaces, the parsing of individual `Function`s are generally fast enough to not really warrant trying to cache them in any "smarter" way than by reference. (Hence trying to do caching similar to e.g. Fonts would most likely be a losing proposition, given the amount of data lookup/parsing that'd be required.)

Originally I tried implementing this similar to e.g. the recently added ColorSpace caching (and in a couple of different ways), however it unfortunately turned out to be quite ugly/unwieldy given the sheer number of functions/methods where you'd thus need to pass in a `LocalFunctionCache` instance. (Also, the affected functions/methods didn't exactly have short signatures as-is.)
After going back and forth on this for a while it seemed to me that the simplest, or least "invasive" if you will, solution would be if each `PartialEvaluator` instance had its *own* `PDFFunctionFactory` instance (since the latter is already passed to all of the required code). This way each `PDFFunctionFactory` instances could have a local `Function` cache, without it being necessary to provide a `LocalFunctionCache` instance manually at every `PDFFunctionFactory.{create, createFromArray}` call-site.

Obviously, with this patch, there's now (potentially) more `PDFFunctionFactory` instances than before when the entire document shared just one. However, each such instance is really quite small and it's also tied to a `PartialEvaluator` instance and those are *not* kept alive and/or cached. To reduce the impact of these changes, I've tried to make as many of these structures as possible *lazily initialized*, specifically:

 - The `PDFFunctionFactory`, on `PartialEvaluator` instances, since not all kinds of general parsing actually requires it. For example: `getTextContent` calls won't cause any `Function` to be parsed, and even some `getOperatorList` calls won't trigger `Function` parsing (if a page contains e.g. no Patterns or "complex" ColorSpaces).

 - The `LocalFunctionCache`, on `PDFFunctionFactory` instances, since only certain parsing requires it. Generally speaking, only e.g. Patterns, "complex" ColorSpaces, and/or (some) SoftMasks will trigger any `Function` parsing.

To put these changes into perspective, when loading/rendering all (14) pages of the default `tracemonkey.pdf` file there's now a total of 6 `PDFFunctionFactory` and 1 `LocalFunctionCache` instances created thanks to the lazy initialization.
(If you instead would keep the document-"global" `PDFFunctionFactory` instance and pass around `LocalFunctionCache` instances everywhere, the numbers for the `tracemonkey.pdf` file would be instead be something like 1 `PDFFunctionFactory` and 6 `LocalFunctionCache` instances.)
All-in-all, I thus don't think that the `PDFFunctionFactory` changes should be generally problematic.

With these changes, we can also modify (some) call-sites to pass in a `Reference` rather than the actual `Function` data. This is nice since `Function`s can also be `Streams`, which are not cached on the `XRef` instance (given their potential size), and this way we can avoid unnecessary lookups and thus save some additional time/resources.

Obviously I had intended to include (standard) benchmark results with these changes, but for reasons I don't really understand the test run-time (even with `master`) of the document in issue 2541 is quite a bit slower than in the development viewer.
However, logging the time it takes for the relevant `PDFFunctionFactory`/`PDFFunction ` parsing shows that it takes *approximately* `0.5 ms` for the `Function` in question. Looking up a cached `Function`, on the other hand, is *one order of magnitude faster* which does add up when the same `Function` is invoked close to 2000 times.
2020-07-04 00:55:18 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
1f7175542e
Merge pull request #12039 from Snuffleupagus/Node-utils
[api-minor] Use the `NodeCanvasFactory`/`NodeCMapReaderFactory` classes as defaults in Node.js environments (issue 11900)
2020-07-04 00:42:52 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
4a7e29865d [api-minor] Use the NodeCanvasFactory/NodeCMapReaderFactory classes as defaults in Node.js environments (issue 11900)
This moves, and slightly simplifies, code that's currently residing in the unit-test utils into the actual library, such that it's bundled with `GENERIC`-builds and used in e.g. the API-code.

As an added bonus, this also brings out-of-the-box support for CMaps in e.g. the Node.js examples.
2020-07-02 04:44:23 +02:00
Brendan Dahl
fe3df495cc
Merge pull request #12040 from wojtekmaj/replace-non-inclusive
Replace non-inclusive "whitelist" term with "allowlist"
2020-07-01 15:41:41 -07:00
Tim van der Meij
ec635b822a
Merge pull request #12044 from Snuffleupagus/issue-12010
Adjust the heuristics used when dealing with rectangles, i.e. `re` operators, with zero width/height (issue 12010)
2020-07-02 00:16:28 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
fef24658e7 Adjust the heuristics used when dealing with rectangles, i.e. re operators, with zero width/height (issue 12010) 2020-07-02 00:02:49 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
75fed02630
Merge pull request #12043 from Snuffleupagus/issue-4260-test
Add a reduced test-case for issue 4260 (PR 4521 follow-up)
2020-07-01 23:51:21 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
3359739ffe
Merge pull request #12036 from Snuffleupagus/test-renderTaskOnContinue
Add at least *some* test-coverage for the `RenderTask.onContinue` functionality
2020-07-01 23:48:37 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
4097c83602
Merge pull request #12049 from Snuffleupagus/eslint_no-promise-executor-return
Enable the `no-promise-executor-return` ESLint rule
2020-07-01 23:44:28 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
4bc5bc454e Enable the no-promise-executor-return ESLint rule
Please see https://eslint.org/docs/rules/no-promise-executor-return for additional information.
2020-07-01 13:01:39 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
e451cabe37 Add a reduced test-case for issue 4260 (PR 4521 follow-up) 2020-06-30 09:26:41 +02:00
Brendan Dahl
bce306f168
Merge pull request #12041 from sylvestre/patch-1
Replace Mozilla Labs by just Mozilla
2020-06-29 13:36:06 -07:00
Sylvestre Ledru
529062a61b
Replace Mozilla Labs by just Mozilla
Mozilla labs isn't a thing
2020-06-29 17:48:35 +02:00
Wojciech Maj
78970bbbe1
Replace non-inclusive "whitelist" term with "allowlist" 2020-06-29 17:15:14 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
4a5b68e077 Add at least *some* test-coverage for the RenderTask.onContinue functionality
The default viewer, and thus Firefox, depends on the `RenderTask.onContinue` functionality to pause/continue rendering (such that the most visible page always renders first).
Despite this functionality thus being very important, it has however never actually been tested *at all* as far as I can tell. Hence this patch which adds a new boolean `renderTaskOnContinue` parameter (`false` by default), that can be used to force a reference-test to use the `RenderTask.onContinue` code-path in the `InternalRenderTask` class.

Note that I purposely made this new reference-test behaviour *optional*, since I didn't want to negatively affect the general runtime of the tests (given that there's a slight delay added to the rendering). Also, for e.g. benchmarking you'd most likely want to stay away from the `RenderTask.onContinue` functionality for similar reasons.
2020-06-29 00:38:34 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
9993397e30
Merge pull request #12032 from Snuffleupagus/update-packages
Update packages and translations
2020-06-28 15:24:53 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
93b1887512 Update l10n files 2020-06-27 11:37:41 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
ff3fbb91b9 Fix *most* vulnerabilities reported by npm audit
This was automatically, by using the `npm audit fix` command.
2020-06-27 11:32:51 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
1d6d1c78ae Update npm packages 2020-06-27 11:30:30 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
d8d6a98418
Merge pull request #12028 from Snuffleupagus/issue-11124
Attempt to detect inline images which contain "EI" sequence in the actual image data (issue 11124)
2020-06-26 23:34:54 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
43c2219517
Merge pull request #12024 from DylanLacey/update_needle
Update Needle to 2.5.0 or greater.
2020-06-26 23:15:51 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
28d2ada59c Attempt to detect inline images which contain "EI" sequence in the actual image data (issue 11124)
This should reduce the possibility of accidentally truncating some inline images, while *not* causing the "EI" detection to become significantly slower.[1]
There's obviously a possibility that these added checks are not sufficient to catch *every* single case of "EI" sequences within the actual inline image data, but without specific test-cases I decided against over-engineering the solution here.

*Please note:* The interpolation issues are somewhat orthogonal to the main issue here, which is the truncated image, and it's already tracked elsewhere.

---
[1] I've looked at the issue a few times, and this is the first approach that I was able to come up with that didn't cause *unacceptable* performance regressions in e.g. issue 2618.
2020-06-26 13:15:06 +02:00
Dylan Lacey
f2b295882f Update Needle to 2.5.0 or greater.
Versions of `needle` prior to `2.5.0` cannot cope with redirects (as documented: https://github.com/tomas/needle/issues/312).

This prevents prebuilt `canvas` binaries from being downloaded on MacOS,
requiring the global install of its dependencies.

Updating Needle restores it to functionality, addressing this.  It also avoids
the need to add `request` to `package.json`; it also obsoletes https://github.com/mozilla/pdf.js/pull/12018.
2020-06-25 13:54:54 +10:00
Tim van der Meij
276d917b7c
Merge pull request #12012 from Snuffleupagus/ColorSpace-parse-cache
Improve (local) caching of parsed `ColorSpace`s (PR 12001 follow-up)
2020-06-25 00:06:32 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
b8e1352934 Stop passing in unnecessary parameters when parsing the Alternate entry of ICCBased ColorSpaces (PR 9659 follow-up)
With the changes made in PR 9659, `ColorSpace.fromIR` no longer takes a second `pdfFunctionFactory` parameter and there's thus one call-site that can be simplified.
2020-06-24 23:53:10 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
19d7976483 Improve (local) caching of parsed ColorSpaces (PR 12001 follow-up)
This patch contains the following *notable* improvements:
 - Changes the `ColorSpace.parse` call-sites to, where possible, pass in a reference rather than actual ColorSpace data (necessary for the next point).
 - Adds (local) caching of `ColorSpace`s by `Ref`, when applicable, in addition the caching by name. This (generally) improves `ColorSpace` caching for e.g. the SMask code-paths.
 - Extends the (local) `ColorSpace` caching to also apply when handling Images and Patterns, thus further reducing unneeded re-parsing.
 - Adds a new `ColorSpace.parseAsync` method, almost identical to the existing `ColorSpace.parse` one, but returning a Promise instead (this simplifies some code in the `PartialEvaluator`).
2020-06-24 23:53:10 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
51e87b9248 Add a proper LocalColorSpaceCache class, rather than piggybacking on the image one (PR 12001 follow-up)
This will allow caching of ColorSpaces by either `Name` *or* `Ref`, which doesn't really make sense for images, thus allowing (better) caching for ColorSpaces used with e.g. Images and Patterns.
2020-06-24 23:53:10 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
e22bc483a5 Re-factor ColorSpace.parse to take a parameter object, rather than a bunch of (randomly) ordered parameters
Given the number of existing parameters, this will avoid needlessly unwieldy call-sites especially with upcoming changes in later patches.
2020-06-24 23:53:10 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
ac4a5c3ace
Merge pull request #12021 from Snuffleupagus/move-fetchBuiltInCMap
Move the `fetchBuiltInCMap` method to the `PartialEvaluator.prototype`
2020-06-24 23:44:52 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
f0708717a9 Move the fetchBuiltInCMap method to the PartialEvaluator.prototype
Defining this *inline* in the "constructor" looks slightly weird (I really don't know why I wrote it like that originally), and it can simply be changed to a regular method instead.
2020-06-24 17:29:47 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
c1cb9ee9fc
Merge pull request #12016 from Snuffleupagus/issue-8078
Tweak the `QueueOptimizer` to recognize `OPS.paintImageMaskXObject` operators as *repeated* when the "skew" transformation matrix elements are non-zero (issue 8078)
2020-06-21 19:38:27 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
3c81b5e26e
Merge pull request #12017 from Snuffleupagus/api-intentStates-Map
Convert the `PDFPageProxy.intentStates` property from an `Object` to a `Map`
2020-06-21 19:30:34 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
4cb0c032f3 Convert the PDFPageProxy.intentStates property from an Object to a Map
As can be seen in the code there's a handful of places where this structure needs to be iterated, something that becomes cumbersome when dealing with `Object`s. Hence, by changing this to a `Map` instead we can both simplify the code and avoid creating unnecessary closures.

Particularily the `PDFPageProxy._tryCleanup` method becomes a lot more readable, at least in my opinion.

Finally, since this property is intended to be "private" the name is adjusted to reflect that.
2020-06-21 17:02:42 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
cabc2cc4fc Add a InternalRenderTask.completed getter and use it to simplify PDFPageProxy._destroy
This patch aims to simplify the `PDFPageProxy._destroy` method, by:
 - Replacing the unnecessary `forEach` with a "regular" `for`-loop instead.
 - Use a more appropriate variable name, since `intentState.renderTasks` contain instances of `InternalRenderTask`.
 - Move the "is rendering completed"-handling to a new `InternalRenderTask.completed` getter, to abstract away some (mostly) internal `InternalRenderTask` state.
2020-06-21 15:56:14 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
a04a5d8325 Tweak the loop in ChunkedStreamManager.abort to clarify what's being iterated (PR 11985 follow-up)
In hindsight, using the `for (let [key, value] of myMap) { ... }`-format when we don't care about the `key` probably wasn't such a great idea. Since `Map`s have explicit support for iterating either `key`s or `value`s, we should probably use that instead here.
2020-06-21 11:29:05 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
e18fa3fc45 Tweak the QueueOptimizer to recognize OPS.paintImageMaskXObject operators as *repeated* when the "skew" transformation matrix elements are non-zero (issue 8078)
*First of all, I should mention that my understanding of the finer details of the `QueueOptimizer` (and its related `CanvasGraphics` methods) is somewhat limited.*
Hence I'm not sure if there's actually a very good reason for *only* considering ImageMasks where the "skew" transformation matrix elements are zero as *repeated*, however simply looking at the code I just don't see why these elements cannot be non-zero as long as they are *all identical* for the ImageMasks.
Furthermore, looking at the *group* case (which is what we're currently falling back to), there's no particular limitation placed upon the transformation matrix elements.

While this patch obviously isn't enough to *completely* fix the issue, since there should be a visible Pattern rendered as well[1], it seem (at least to me) like enough of an improvement that submitting this is justified.
With these changes the referenced PDF document will no longer hang the *entire* browser, and rendering also finishes in a *reasonable* time (< 10 seconds for me) which seem fine given the *huge* number of identical inline images present.[2]

---
[1] Temporarily changing the Pattern to a solid color *does* render the correct/expected area, which suggests that the remaining problem is a pre-existing issue related to the Pattern-handling itself rather than the `QueueOptimizer` functionality.

[2] The document isn't exactly rendered immediately in e.g. Adobe Reader either.
2020-06-20 12:18:48 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
8cfdfb237a
Merge pull request #12005 from Snuffleupagus/cff-class
Convert the code in `src/core/cff_parser.js` to use ES6 classes
2020-06-17 23:30:28 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
3067917582
Merge pull request #12004 from Snuffleupagus/worker-class
Convert the code in `src/core/worker.js` to use ES6 classes
2020-06-17 23:23:17 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
880a0a0f59 Convert the code in src/core/cff_parser.js to use ES6 classes
This removes multiple instances of `// eslint-disable-next-line no-shadow`, which our old pseudo-classes necessitated.

*Please note:* I'm purposely not doing any `var` to `let`/`const` conversion here, since it's generally better to (if possible) do that automatically on e.g. a directory basis instead.
2020-06-16 12:33:21 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
fb9b574f3d Convert the code in src/core/worker.js to use ES6 classes
This removes one instance of `// eslint-disable-next-line no-shadow`, which our old pseudo-classes necessitated.

*Please note:* I'm purposely not doing any `var` to `let`/`const` conversion here, since it's generally better to (if possible) do that automatically on e.g. a directory basis instead.
2020-06-16 11:54:59 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
6bb64da1c3
Merge pull request #12002 from Snuffleupagus/cff-encodeNumber
Small improvements in `CFFCompiler.encodeNumber` and `CFFCompiler.encodeFloat`
2020-06-15 23:49:14 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
87b089ba42 Lazily initialize, and cache, the regular expression used in CFFCompiler.encodeFloat
There's no particular reason for re-creating the regular expression over and over for every `encodeFloat` invocation, as far as I can tell.
2020-06-15 13:51:28 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
517d92a121 Simplify the "is integer" checks in CFFCompiler.encodeNumber
The `isNaN` check is obviously redundant, since `NaN` is the only value that isn't equal to itself; see https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Global_Objects/NaN#Examples

The `parseFloat`/`parseInt` comparison would make sense if the `value` ever contains a String, which however is never actually the case. Besides looking through the code, I've also run the entire test-suite locally with `assert(typeof value === "number", "encodeNumber");` added at the top of the method and there were no failures.

Hence we can simplify the "is integer" check a bit in the `CFFCompiler.encodeNumber` method.
2020-06-15 13:51:20 +02:00
Tim van der Meij
a91f24cda9
Merge pull request #12001 from Snuffleupagus/cache-ColorSpace-locally
Add local caching of `ColorSpace`s, by name, in `PartialEvaluator.getOperatorList` (issue 2504)
2020-06-14 13:20:13 +02:00
Jonas Jenwald
5c39de805c Add local caching of ColorSpaces, by name, in PartialEvaluator.getOperatorList (issue 2504)
By caching parsed `ColorSpace`s, we thus don't need to re-parse the same data over and over which saves CPU cycles *and* reduces peak memory usage. (Obviously persistent memory usage *may* increase a tiny bit, but since the caching is done per `PartialEvaluator.getOperatorList` invocation and given that `ColorSpace` instances generally hold very little data this shouldn't be much of an issue.)
Furthermore, by caching `ColorSpace`s we can also lookup the already parsed ones *synchronously* during the `OperatorList` building, instead of having to defer to the event loop/microtask queue since the parsing is done asynchronously (such that error handling is easier).

Possible future improvements:
 - Cache/lookup parsed `ColorSpaces` used in `Pattern`s and `Image`s.
 - Attempt to cache *local* `ColorSpace`s by reference as well, in addition to only by name, assuming that there's documents where that would be beneficial and that it's not too difficult to implement.
 - Assuming there's documents that would benefit from it, also cache repeated `ColorSpace`s *globally* as well.

Given that we've never, until now, been doing *any* caching of parsed `ColorSpace`s and that even using a simple name-only *local* cache helps tremendously in pathological cases, I purposely decided against complicating the implementation too much initially.
Also, compared to parsing of `Image`s, simply creating a `ColorSpace` instance isn't that expensive (hence I'd be somewhat surprised if adding a *global* cache would help much).

---

This patch was tested using:
 - The default `tracemonkey` PDF file, which was included mostly to show that "normal" documents aren't negatively affected by these changes.
 - The PDF file from issue 2504, i.e. https://dl-ctlg.panasonic.com/jp/manual/sd/sd_rbm1000_0.pdf, where most pages will switch *thousands* of times between a handful of `ColorSpace`s.

with the following manifest file:
```
[
    {  "id": "tracemonkey",
       "file": "pdfs/tracemonkey.pdf",
       "md5": "9a192d8b1a7dc652a19835f6f08098bd",
       "rounds": 100,
       "type": "eq"
    },
    {  "id": "issue2504",
       "file": "../web/pdfs/issue2504.pdf",
       "md5": "",
       "rounds": 20,
       "type": "eq"
    }
]
```

which gave the following results when comparing this patch against the `master` branch:
 - Overall
```
-- Grouped By browser, pdf, stat --
browser | pdf         | stat         | Count | Baseline(ms) | Current(ms) |  +/- |     %  | Result(P<.05)
------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | ---- | ------ | -------------
firefox | issue2504   | Overall      |   640 |          977 |         497 | -479 | -49.08 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | Page Request |   640 |            3 |           4 |    1 |  59.18 |
firefox | issue2504   | Rendering    |   640 |          974 |         493 | -481 | -49.37 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | Overall      |  1400 |          116 |         111 |   -5 |  -4.43 |
firefox | tracemonkey | Page Request |  1400 |            2 |           2 |    0 |  -2.86 |
firefox | tracemonkey | Rendering    |  1400 |          114 |         109 |   -5 |  -4.47 |
```

 - Page-specific
```
-- Grouped By browser, pdf, page, stat --
browser | pdf         | page | stat         | Count | Baseline(ms) | Current(ms) |   +/- |      %  | Result(P<.05)
------- | ----------- | ---- | ------------ | ----- | ------------ | ----------- | ----- | ------- | -------------
firefox | issue2504   | 0    | Overall      |    20 |         2295 |        1268 | -1027 |  -44.76 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 0    | Page Request |    20 |            6 |           7 |     1 |   15.32 |
firefox | issue2504   | 0    | Rendering    |    20 |         2288 |        1260 | -1028 |  -44.93 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 1    | Overall      |    20 |         3059 |        2806 |  -252 |   -8.25 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 1    | Page Request |    20 |           11 |          14 |     3 |   23.25 |        slower
firefox | issue2504   | 1    | Rendering    |    20 |         3047 |        2792 |  -255 |   -8.37 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 2    | Overall      |    20 |          411 |         295 |  -116 |  -28.20 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 2    | Page Request |    20 |            2 |          42 |    40 | 1897.62 |
firefox | issue2504   | 2    | Rendering    |    20 |          409 |         253 |  -156 |  -38.09 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 3    | Overall      |    20 |          736 |         299 |  -437 |  -59.34 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 3    | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     0 |    0.00 |
firefox | issue2504   | 3    | Rendering    |    20 |          734 |         297 |  -437 |  -59.49 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 4    | Overall      |    20 |          356 |         458 |   102 |   28.63 |
firefox | issue2504   | 4    | Page Request |    20 |            1 |           2 |     1 |   57.14 |        slower
firefox | issue2504   | 4    | Rendering    |    20 |          354 |         455 |   101 |   28.53 |
firefox | issue2504   | 5    | Overall      |    20 |         1381 |         765 |  -616 |  -44.59 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 5    | Page Request |    20 |            3 |           5 |     2 |   50.00 |        slower
firefox | issue2504   | 5    | Rendering    |    20 |         1378 |         760 |  -617 |  -44.81 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 6    | Overall      |    20 |          757 |         299 |  -459 |  -60.57 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 6    | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           5 |     3 |  150.00 |        slower
firefox | issue2504   | 6    | Rendering    |    20 |          755 |         294 |  -462 |  -61.11 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 7    | Overall      |    20 |          394 |         302 |   -92 |  -23.39 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 7    | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           1 |    -1 |  -34.88 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 7    | Rendering    |    20 |          392 |         301 |   -91 |  -23.32 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 8    | Overall      |    20 |         2875 |         979 | -1896 |  -65.95 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 8    | Page Request |    20 |            1 |           2 |     0 |   11.11 |
firefox | issue2504   | 8    | Rendering    |    20 |         2874 |         978 | -1896 |  -65.99 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 9    | Overall      |    20 |          700 |         332 |  -368 |  -52.60 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 9    | Page Request |    20 |            3 |           2 |     0 |   -4.00 |
firefox | issue2504   | 9    | Rendering    |    20 |          698 |         329 |  -368 |  -52.78 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 10   | Overall      |    20 |         3296 |         926 | -2370 |  -71.91 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 10   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     0 |  -18.75 |
firefox | issue2504   | 10   | Rendering    |    20 |         3293 |         924 | -2370 |  -71.96 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 11   | Overall      |    20 |          524 |         197 |  -327 |  -62.34 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 11   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           3 |     1 |   58.54 |
firefox | issue2504   | 11   | Rendering    |    20 |          522 |         194 |  -328 |  -62.81 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 12   | Overall      |    20 |          752 |         369 |  -384 |  -50.98 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 12   | Page Request |    20 |            3 |           2 |    -1 |  -36.51 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 12   | Rendering    |    20 |          749 |         367 |  -382 |  -51.05 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 13   | Overall      |    20 |          679 |         487 |  -193 |  -28.38 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 13   | Page Request |    20 |            4 |           2 |    -2 |  -48.68 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 13   | Rendering    |    20 |          676 |         485 |  -191 |  -28.28 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 14   | Overall      |    20 |          474 |         283 |  -191 |  -40.26 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 14   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           4 |     2 |   78.57 |
firefox | issue2504   | 14   | Rendering    |    20 |          471 |         279 |  -192 |  -40.79 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 15   | Overall      |    20 |          860 |         618 |  -241 |  -28.05 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 15   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           3 |     0 |   10.87 |
firefox | issue2504   | 15   | Rendering    |    20 |          857 |         616 |  -241 |  -28.15 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 16   | Overall      |    20 |          389 |         243 |  -147 |  -37.71 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 16   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     0 |    2.33 |
firefox | issue2504   | 16   | Rendering    |    20 |          387 |         240 |  -147 |  -37.94 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 17   | Overall      |    20 |         1484 |         672 |  -812 |  -54.70 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 17   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           3 |     1 |   37.21 |
firefox | issue2504   | 17   | Rendering    |    20 |         1482 |         669 |  -812 |  -54.84 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 18   | Overall      |    20 |          575 |         252 |  -323 |  -56.12 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 18   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     0 |  -16.22 |
firefox | issue2504   | 18   | Rendering    |    20 |          573 |         251 |  -322 |  -56.24 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 19   | Overall      |    20 |          517 |         227 |  -290 |  -56.08 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 19   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     0 |   21.62 |
firefox | issue2504   | 19   | Rendering    |    20 |          515 |         225 |  -290 |  -56.37 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 20   | Overall      |    20 |          668 |         670 |     2 |    0.31 |
firefox | issue2504   | 20   | Page Request |    20 |            4 |           2 |    -1 |  -34.29 |
firefox | issue2504   | 20   | Rendering    |    20 |          664 |         667 |     3 |    0.49 |
firefox | issue2504   | 21   | Overall      |    20 |          486 |         309 |  -177 |  -36.44 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 21   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     0 |   16.13 |
firefox | issue2504   | 21   | Rendering    |    20 |          484 |         307 |  -177 |  -36.60 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 22   | Overall      |    20 |          543 |         267 |  -276 |  -50.85 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 22   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     0 |   10.26 |
firefox | issue2504   | 22   | Rendering    |    20 |          541 |         265 |  -276 |  -51.07 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 23   | Overall      |    20 |         3246 |         871 | -2375 |  -73.17 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 23   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           3 |     1 |   37.21 |
firefox | issue2504   | 23   | Rendering    |    20 |         3243 |         868 | -2376 |  -73.25 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 24   | Overall      |    20 |          379 |         156 |  -223 |  -58.83 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 24   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     0 |   -2.86 |
firefox | issue2504   | 24   | Rendering    |    20 |          378 |         154 |  -223 |  -59.10 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 25   | Overall      |    20 |          176 |         127 |   -50 |  -28.19 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 25   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           1 |     0 |  -15.63 |
firefox | issue2504   | 25   | Rendering    |    20 |          175 |         125 |   -49 |  -28.31 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 26   | Overall      |    20 |          181 |         108 |   -74 |  -40.67 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 26   | Page Request |    20 |            3 |           2 |    -1 |  -39.13 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 26   | Rendering    |    20 |          178 |         105 |   -72 |  -40.69 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 27   | Overall      |    20 |          208 |         104 |  -104 |  -49.92 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 27   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |     1 |   48.39 |
firefox | issue2504   | 27   | Rendering    |    20 |          206 |         102 |  -104 |  -50.64 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 28   | Overall      |    20 |          241 |         111 |  -131 |  -54.16 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 28   | Page Request |    20 |            2 |           2 |    -1 |  -33.33 |
firefox | issue2504   | 28   | Rendering    |    20 |          239 |         109 |  -130 |  -54.39 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 29   | Overall      |    20 |          321 |         196 |  -125 |  -39.05 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 29   | Page Request |    20 |            1 |           2 |     0 |   17.86 |
firefox | issue2504   | 29   | Rendering    |    20 |          319 |         194 |  -126 |  -39.35 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 30   | Overall      |    20 |          651 |         271 |  -380 |  -58.41 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 30   | Page Request |    20 |            1 |           2 |     1 |   50.00 |
firefox | issue2504   | 30   | Rendering    |    20 |          649 |         269 |  -381 |  -58.60 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 31   | Overall      |    20 |         1635 |         647 |  -988 |  -60.42 |        faster
firefox | issue2504   | 31   | Page Request |    20 |            1 |           2 |     0 |   30.43 |
firefox | issue2504   | 31   | Rendering    |    20 |         1634 |         645 |  -988 |  -60.49 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 0    | Overall      |   100 |           51 |          51 |     0 |    0.02 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 0    | Page Request |   100 |            1 |           1 |     0 |   -4.76 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 0    | Rendering    |   100 |           50 |          50 |     0 |    0.12 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 1    | Overall      |   100 |           97 |          91 |    -5 |   -5.52 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 1    | Page Request |   100 |            3 |           3 |     0 |   -1.32 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 1    | Rendering    |   100 |           94 |          88 |    -5 |   -5.73 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 2    | Overall      |   100 |           40 |          40 |     0 |    0.50 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 2    | Page Request |   100 |            1 |           1 |     0 |    3.16 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 2    | Rendering    |   100 |           39 |          39 |     0 |    0.54 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 3    | Overall      |   100 |           62 |          62 |    -1 |   -0.94 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 3    | Page Request |   100 |            1 |           1 |     0 |   17.05 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 3    | Rendering    |   100 |           61 |          61 |    -1 |   -1.11 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 4    | Overall      |   100 |           56 |          58 |     2 |    3.41 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 4    | Page Request |   100 |            1 |           1 |     0 |   15.31 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 4    | Rendering    |   100 |           55 |          57 |     2 |    3.23 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 5    | Overall      |   100 |           73 |          71 |    -2 |   -2.28 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 5    | Page Request |   100 |            2 |           2 |     0 |   12.20 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 5    | Rendering    |   100 |           71 |          69 |    -2 |   -2.69 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 6    | Overall      |   100 |           85 |          69 |   -16 |  -18.73 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 6    | Page Request |   100 |            2 |           2 |     0 |   -9.90 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 6    | Rendering    |   100 |           83 |          67 |   -16 |  -18.97 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 7    | Overall      |   100 |           65 |          64 |     0 |   -0.37 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 7    | Page Request |   100 |            1 |           1 |     0 |  -11.94 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 7    | Rendering    |   100 |           63 |          63 |     0 |   -0.05 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 8    | Overall      |   100 |           53 |          54 |     1 |    2.04 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 8    | Page Request |   100 |            1 |           1 |     0 |   17.02 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 8    | Rendering    |   100 |           52 |          53 |     1 |    1.82 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 9    | Overall      |   100 |           79 |          73 |    -6 |   -7.86 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 9    | Page Request |   100 |            2 |           2 |     0 |  -15.14 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 9    | Rendering    |   100 |           77 |          71 |    -6 |   -7.86 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 10   | Overall      |   100 |          545 |         519 |   -27 |   -4.86 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 10   | Page Request |   100 |           14 |          13 |     0 |   -3.56 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 10   | Rendering    |   100 |          532 |         506 |   -26 |   -4.90 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 11   | Overall      |   100 |           42 |          41 |    -1 |   -2.50 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 11   | Page Request |   100 |            1 |           1 |     0 |  -27.42 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 11   | Rendering    |   100 |           41 |          40 |    -1 |   -1.75 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 12   | Overall      |   100 |          350 |         332 |   -18 |   -5.16 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 12   | Page Request |   100 |            3 |           3 |     0 |   -5.17 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 12   | Rendering    |   100 |          347 |         329 |   -18 |   -5.15 |        faster
firefox | tracemonkey | 13   | Overall      |   100 |           31 |          31 |     0 |    0.52 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 13   | Page Request |   100 |            1 |           1 |     0 |    4.95 |
firefox | tracemonkey | 13   | Rendering    |   100 |           30 |          30 |     0 |    0.20 |
```
2020-06-14 11:51:45 +02:00